Why can't India’s airlines make inflight announcements in regional languages?
One of the common feedback from India’s airline passengers-
mostly from South India is that airlines are not making in-flight announcements
in their regional languages. Almost all announcements are made only in English
and Hindi, putting many passengers whose mother tongue could be
Kannada/Tamil/Malayalam etc at a disadvantage. Unless their Hindi/English is
good, they can’t make good understanding of what is being announced. This could
be a danger during real emergency.
In this post, let us assess what it takes for airlines to
make in-flight announcements in regional languages.
Is it fair to drag airlines into language war and add to their already long list of complexities and headaches?
This is for each passenger to decide. If you think getting served in your own language is really useful/required then ask for it. For those who're not strong in Hindi/English I am sure regional language will help. Serving in local language also gives the airline some brownie points and will help get more loyal customers. Most countries world wide serve their customers in multiple languages (Singapore has a 3 language policy- English, Chinese and Tamil)- Many European airlines service in their home country language besides English. Just that in India it is a lot more complex with 20+ languages to cater, so airlines, regulators and passengers need to consider these complexities.
Hyderabad airport serves in 4 languages- English, Hindi, Urdu, Telugu. Almost all airports do use local language- the above concern is only for in-flight announcements by airlines, which is done in only say English and Hindi even for a Chennai-Madurai flight.
Arguments against the need for using regional languages in-flight
Argument
|
Counter Argument
|
There’re too many languages in
India- not possible to keep explaining in every language
|
Demand is to use regional
language prevailing in flight origin, destination. At max this will result in
need for 4 languages- English, Hindi (assuming it is retained), Regional
Language 1 and Regional Language 2 (For a Chennai-Kochi flight, Tamil &
Malayalam, For Chennai –Coimbatore flight, only Tamil extra.
|
Cabin crew are from different
parts of India and keep flying to dozens of cities every day all around the
country- they can’t be expected to learn every regional language
|
Fair enough. At the minimum
recorded announcements can be used. At the best, airlines can ensure at least
one of the cabin crew speaks regional language
|
Air Passengers are fairly
educated people- they can understand English/Hindi
|
Not true. Now lots of people
are taking to the skies, not just well educated people. Local language is
more effective on these passengers
|
No one really cares for
inflight announcement- why bother with multiple languages
|
Of course most regular
passengers are used to it and don’t pay attention. But the safety
announcement and other rules are there for a reason. In case of real emergency
following/not following these instructions can make a difference between life
and death. Not being able to understand these instructions will make it worse
for affected passengers and others.
|
Is it impossible to use regional languages?
No. If there is a will, there is a way. Several
international airlines are making attempt to use regional languages of India to
get closer to country’s passengers. Lufthansa makes critical announcements in
Tamil on its Chennai bound flight. [Read my Lufthansa Premium economy experience] Even menu are in Tamil. Indians flying in
few other airlines have also experienced hospitality in their own language and
have appreciated it.
So what is the problem with India based airlines to use regional languages?
1. Demand is not strong enough: I believe the airline bosses haven’t felt the need to service Indians in their regional languages- except some occasional facebook rants, most passengers have got used to service in Hindi and English, hence demand for regional language hasn’t been strong enough.
2. Rostering issues: An aircraft may fly through half a dozen language zones in a single day- it may start from Delhi, fly to Mumbai, then to Kochi, then onwards to Chennai, then to Vizag, then to Kolkata and to Guwahati. So which language cabin crew to assign to this aircraft? Obviously not possible to have 7+ crew with at least one knowing Marathi, Malayalam, Tamil, Hindi, Telugu, Bengali and Assamese. This adds a new level of complexity to cabin crew hiring, training and deployment process, which means more money.
- Play emergency procedures and critical announcements in regional languages, through recorded audio if trained crew is not available
- Support regional languages in airline app. Customers who want service in specific language should be able to download and get updates/info in their own language
- Try to manage crew hiring and rostering such that wherever possible someone speaking local language is onboard. May be not possible all the time on all the flight, but if a passenger wanting local language service gets it in say 2 out of 10 flights, he will still be happy and be loyal to the airline. Over time airlines can try how to improvise on this.
- I feel it is lot easier to support regional languages on the ATR fleet which keep flying short haul distances within a state or within a few states. If there's an ATR doing rounds only in South India-say Hyderabad-Chennai-Bengaluru-Kochi-Goa-Hyderabad, then it is easier to staff it such that crew can speak at least 2-3 of the 4-5 South Indian languages. If a crew knows one south Indian language, he/she can easily pickup a few critical words in one other south Indian language as well.
What you can do as a passenger?
- Use available feedback opportunities to communicate to airline that you'd prefer services in your language.
- If you find an airline serving you in your language, do leave a positive feedback and patron that airline more.
Nothing is impossible- if companies feel the pressure or realize the benefits of doing something, they will at least try.
What are your thoughts? Would you vote for airlines to serve you in your mother tongue? Would you prefer an airline that does over another airline that only uses English & Hindi, even if the other airline is cheaper and more comfortable? Do share below.
Similar: Some of the best in-flight videos *
Similar: Some of the best in-flight videos *
Agree that having recorded safety measures is best option as these are very important. However having crew that is fluent in all languages of flight route is not possible. What if flight crew asks for assistance to some passenger who could act as translator if a customer who is not equipped in Hindi or English is on board? That way the regular conversation like asking flight attendants for meal options or other mundane help which has nothing to do with safety instructions can be managed.
ReplyDeleteYes, usually co-passengers will help in case of such issues
DeleteIf there are in-flight entertainment systems- headphone, screen etc, then this can become easy.
ReplyDeletePre-recorded instructions can be there.
Passengers can wear the headphones, choose their language & hear & read the instructions! But, not all flights have this facility.
Airlines are now moving from having inflight entertainment system to streaming entertainment on passenger's own devices- lot economical. So airlnes can provide local language content on the app.
DeleteCivil Aviation rules in India mandates use of English and Hindi in all flights/routes leaving optional status for State official languages. When there is no policy or rule, flight operators/companies nicely ignore it . This is usual flawed language policy in India, where Hindi knowing people are given all advantages and Hindi will used beside English all over the country though Hindi is not commonly used in most parts of India. It is high time for govt to frame and enforce policies to mandate the use of source and destination places where flight is operating.. and at least one or two crew must be trained with conversation abilities in required languages. Its a business where customer pay for service and they have to get served comfortably.
ReplyDeleteYes
Delete